MINORITY OPINION
Time must be speeding up. Can someone tell me where the heck January went? I
don't think I like this new century. Actually, it doesn't seem that different
so far, but I do miss the 90's just because there's no snazzy name for the
new decade. One of my tag lines used to be, "That's very 90's of you!" Now
what can I say? "That's very Double-Ought of you!?" The new year is missing
something, don't you think?
Maybe Clinton is right-- it's because the Union is in the best state it's
ever been and our problems are reduced to pretty trivial levels. Think about
it. So far the biggest controversy in the new year/decade/century blah-blah
is about aliens getting citizenship. Sorry, spelled that wrong. Elian's
getting citizenship. You know, that flap about Congress considering giving
one particular alien, Elian Gonzalez, citizenship. A real heavy hitter of a
controversy. Me? I think we should send him back to Cuba; let the INS do its
job. It amazes me to hear all those Family Values Republicans falling over
themselves trying to keep this kid from living with his dad.
I'm not trying to put him down; my heart goes out to him. He lost his mom
getting here and that's tough enough for an adult, let alone when you're six.
But if he landed on the West Coast, there'd be no question about sending him
back because he'd be just another illegal immigrant like from Mexico, El
Salvador or increasingly, China. It would make no difference, heck, the East
Coast would send him back too if he were HAITIAN. There are legal ways to get
into this country, what's really so different about Cuban boat people anyway?
Oh right, I almost forgot, this is all because of communism. Fidel Castro may
be a lot of things, but as communist rulers go, he's pretty benign. Whatever
folks may have lost in his Cuban Revolution forty years ago and barring those
Russian Nukes that were pointed at us for a few weeks back in 1962, at least
with Castro there's no record of pogroms or other mass terror that he's
responsible for. I'm sure there are more than a few people jailed for
speaking up in favor of capitalism and such, but then we have plenty of
people in jail here for political reasons too. And on the plus side, there's
state medical care under Castro's regime and the literacy rate may be even a
little higher there than it is here.
So what drove Elian's mom to make the trip? Grinding poverty. Caused by a
decades old US trade embargo and more recently the lack of a Russian market
for Cuban sugar. Now, we trade billions with China, which is still officially
communist, why can't we just normalize relations with Cuba? Then Elian could
get a passport to visit relatives in BOTH countries. End of problem.
Sorry to get off on that. I really wanted to write about race relations since
it's Black History Month. The perfect topic for an average white guy like me,
right? But it's kind of parallel to Elian's ethnicity problem, isn't it? I
wish race wasn't such a big deal though. Race is such emotionally charged
word, but it's on pretty flimsy grounds as a concept. Certainly it's not
scientific. Would we call a white cat and a black cat two different species?
Of course not. Any truisms you make regarding race have so many exceptions
that when applied to a particular person, the whole idea of race is useless.
It's a generality trap. But we are terribly hung up on it and it persists in
our culture.
Every time a black actor plays a thug or an ignorant fool, some stereotypes
about black people in general get reinforced among people who are receptive
to it. But it doesn't seem to go the other way. Homer Simpson could easily be
a negative racial stereotype, and maybe Mr. Burns too. I'd loathe being
grouped with an drunken ignoramus like Homer or a mendacious skinflint like
Burns, but somehow extrapolation of the stereotype doesn't happen with them.
They stand for only themselves, not Whites as a whole. A whole what though?
White comes in lots of shades. And what does "Black" mean in America anyway?
The races in this country are a lot more mixed than people think. Just ask
the Jefferson/Hemmings clan in Virginia. Even Malcolm X was at least one
quarter white. Who knows what White or Black is? Who cares about stereotypes?
Remember that Beauty and Stupidity both come in all colors. Just let people
be people on their own merits.
Actually we've made a fair amount of progress on that during the 20th
Century. At least racism isn't OFFICIALLY sanctioned anymore. And there have
been lots of individual efforts that have chipped away at racist attitudes.
Maybe it's time to recognize some of the people who made great strides for
equality.
Welcome to the Twentieth Century Awards! (Glitzy brass fanfare, the camera
dollies past rows of formally-dressed famous people clapping and smiling. Cut
to a toothy, clean-cut MC flanked by incredible babes.)
MC: And now, for the man and woman who did more for racial and ethnic harmony
than anyone else in the last 50 years by presenting positive stereotypes in
the media--the envelope, please--this is sooo exciting---
Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz!
(Wild clapping from a few in the audience, rapidly fading into a dumbstruck
silence. Cut to a closeup of Jesse Jackson retrieving his jaw from the floor.)
Yes, that's right. A righteous All-American honey, paraded across American
prime time TV year after year with her Cubano husband, and ethnically NO ONE
CARED ABOUT IT. Fred & Ethel came over just like they would've to anyone
else. America embraced them both for what they were, an incredibly funny
team. Moreover, the team was fronted by a woman! (Gasp!) It's little things
like that that help fight negative stereotypes.
There are plenty of others I could have mentioned, like Gene Roddenberry for
Star Trek, which had the mixed crew and the first interracial kiss on TV and
certainly The Cosby Show, but Lucy and Desi cleared the path for them. In a
way, their subtle, almost subliminal contribution was almost as important as
the bigger civil rights fight waged by Martin Luther King Jr., Rosa Parks, X
and thousands of others. They helped people accept ethnic differences,
especially in kids like me who grew up watching the show.
Maybe that's one reason why I didn't think too much about going from Ohio to
the University of Hawaii, where I instantly became a "haole," a minority. But
then again there wasn't a majority there either. In Hawaii people are aware
of ethnicity but they don't make a big deal of it. Interracial families are
everywhere and lots of people are five or six ethnicities rolled into one. I
was comfortable with that. It mattered a lot to some in my family back in
Ohio though. Before I left I remember my grandmother taking me aside and
telling me very seriously, "The Hawaiian girls are beautiful, but DON'T MARRY
ANY OF THEM." Well, Nana, I didn't. My wife's from Tokyo; I only met her in
Hawaii.
This year there will be the census and I don't know what our hapa-haole kids
should put under "race" on the forms. Maybe everyone should check "other" and
gum up the government's figures on race, because it really doesn't mean a
whole lot. We're all minorities of one and yet we're an awful lot like each
other, like Lucy and Desi proved. Nobody wants racial labels tying us down;
we all really want to be "Strictly Genteel," as Frank Zappa put it, to have a
good life free of that grinding poverty that drives people to desperate boat
trips. One day I hope race and ethnicity will cease to be used as a
yardstick. Something we double-ought to work on, don't you think?
Right now I think I double-ought to get back into the Closet before February
evaporates. After all, I've got a run for the Presidency to prepare for. But
that's a future column. Thanks for reading and until next month, the Closet
is closed.
(C) 2000 Rusty Pipes
OFFICIAL DISCLAIMER: The opinions of Rusty Pipes are not necessarily the
opinions of the editors and publisher of Cosmik Debris Magazine. Indeed, some of us aren't
even remotely capable of H.D. Thoreau-like thoughts no matter how isolated we get. Some of
us, in fact... what? That was LAST month's column? Oh, well then... OFFICIAL DISCLAIMER:
We deny everything. Thank you and Dog bless.